Response to the exaggerations about Persepolis and Pasargad
Unmeasured words and measured answers
the writer : Mr. Yaghesh Kazemi, University Professor
Source: Mr. Yaghesh Kazemi's blog
A review of false claims about Persepolis and Pasargad
The author of “From this Avesta” He decided to weigh the unmeasured speech with the scale of criticism: A speech entitled "Historizing the deviant flow of a deviant topic called Persepolis" by Mr. “God's grace is monotheistic” In the explanatory analytical database “proof” It's been published.
Of course, by studying the statements of Mr. Mohed, it is clear that he is actually narrating the scenarios created by Nasser Pourpirar..
Mr “unified” According to himself, he tried "With reasoningsufficient to show "How historical experts sent by the universitythe west (University of Chicago) With forgery and lies aboutIran's pre-Islamic history and manipulation and deception in constructionPersepolis and making storiesFantasies aboutof that fieldIt has deceived a part of the societyare up using that contextto create divisions between the Muslim people of Iran and other Muslims in the region."!؟
One of the oldest and most accurate engravings from the site of “Persepolis” Between November 8, 1704 and January 23, 1705 “Cornelis de Bruyn” , the Dutch painter and tourist, has been drawn and the condition of the building was much earlier than the restoration measures “Oriental Institute, University of Chicago” it shows.
source: http://odur.let.rug.nl/~drijvers/research/persepol.htm
His first emphasis on the existence of an Elamite ziggurat in the place “Persepolis” It is from the intention of the experts (Eastern Institute) The University of Chicago has been destroyed!? Mr “unified” To prove his claim, he went to a photo in the same university official website He published it with a clear subtitle; Subtitle that explains Clay walls “treasury”Persepolis and “harem” Restored is in the background.
Picture 1 : Clay walls “treasury”The throne of Jamshed … (Year 1935)
source: Institute of Oriental Studies, University of Chicago
Mr “unified” But they said in the explanation of this picture:
«sowhich is clearly evident in the excavationAt the University of Chicago, a huge mud and clay building has been revealed that showsThis area is an Elamite building that was built before the start of constructionStone Hai, centuryhave been active and that activity in the zigguratReligious activities are performedHas been.»
In response, the author asks them to step aside and to “Persepolis” go to see closely that these clay walls have been shortened (And not fade) And the purpose of this, as can be seen in the implementation of straw on the top of the walls, was to preserve the overall plan of the work.. To explain that: The aforementioned clay walls have been pulled out of the soil (1935. Exploration group under supervision “Eric F. Schmidt”), then they saw that they did not have the cost of restoration and the necessary solution to preserve them, so they either had to leave them alone, or they buried them again, or they took this aggressive and decisive method.! And of course this method of restoration (In the 1930s) It is not approved today. now “Ziggurat” Where are these surrounding walls?!
Pictures 2 and 3 : The current state of the walls “treasury”Persepolis, after shortening (Repair the mistake) Clay walls and covering the top of the walls with straw
photo source: Irania Vista Ara
Mr “unified” Then a series of photos and of course a report “Building Engineering System Organization of Tehran Province” which indicates that some motifs were not completely shaved and the site plan of the work was not complete, and by emphasizing the image of a soldier whose beard was not completely shaved, they concluded that "Is this building with such defects for 200 years a place of celebration?Has it been?"
In response, the author says that he is from «no God but God » Just “No God” have said!? Image - for example, the fist of Kharvar- From the detailed repairs of the Achaemenians in the facade of the eastern staircase “Apadana” During the operation of the work, it is presented, which shows how they removed the worn part and the worn-out part of the stone and restored the work by artistically placing a new piece of stone..
Picture 4 : An example of Achaemenid's detailed repairs in the facade of the eastern staircase “Apadana” During the exploitation of the work, which shows how they removed the worn-out part and the worn-out part of the stone and restored the work by artistically placing a new piece of stone..
photo source: reports “Giuseppe Tilia”
Picture 4-1 : The detailed cuts of the restorers of the Achaemenid era in the worn parts of the facade of the eastern staircase. “Apadana” At the time of exploitation of the work, which shows how they removed the worn-out part and the worn-out part of the stone in order to restore the work by artistically placing a new piece of stone..
photo source: reports “Giuseppe Tilia”
Mr “unified” By placing the two images below and their descriptions below :
«Shawl Stone Salem! and possibly a new build with an uncarved column and a plinthColumn with damageIt shows a combination of fake and ridiculous timesgive." «University of Chicago in Commentaries on the Hundred Pillars, referenceThis Sphinx is not a setRidiculous and messed upPut the following in its placeare. This is Kubism! The strange creation was planted instead of the mentioned cow so that its Babylonian identity would be hidden and the forgers could use it for Cyrus and Darius who had never been in Persepolis.End, storymake a thousand and one nights."!؟
They have proved their ignorance of the universally accepted rules and principles of restoration. The author responded to this “Ignorance” along with inviting them to make an official apology to the specialists whom they have accused.
The restoration work done in this direction, not by the Jews “University of Chicago”!? In the 1930s, but by the restorers “Italian Institute of Middle East and Far East” (Try it)It was completed in the 1960s; The set of restoration measures, which is interpreted as “Anastylosis” can be. Explanations of Article 4 of the Global Resolution on the Restoration of Historical Buildings (Approved by Athens – 1931):
«”Anastylosis” It means to re-place the pieces or elements obtained from the building. In the process of combining or reinstalling the building elements of the destroyed parts (Elements that can often be used in other buildings)Sometimes it happens that a part is missing between several building elements. In this case, the restorer will build it for the overall restoration and restoration of the work. But it must be done (Reconstruction of the missing part) to do it in such a way that the viewer can distinguish the new parts from the old with a first glance. In other words, if a member is added to the building, it should be done with specific materials and methods to separate it from the original part.
Picture 5 : Editing A column in the manner of “Anastylosis” (Combining original stones with new restoration stones to complete the board and raise the column.) by restorers “Try it” in Persepolis
photo source: reports “Giuseppe Tilia”
Picture 6 : The efforts of restorers “Try it” To raise the giant stone cow in the portico of the Hall of Hundred Pillars in Persepolis.
photo source: reports “Giuseppe Tilia”
And these words of Hakim Ferdowsi:
Don't call him wise people/ that brought the name of the elders to ugliness
The author continued his previous speech in the criticism of the writing "Historying the deviant flow of a deviant subject called Persepolis", a short look at the other written work of that workshop titled "Pasargad, built by Jews or Iranians?" to the pen “God's grace is monotheistic” has it:
Mr “God's grace is monotheistic” In the introduction of this article, they have stated that: «… This cultural crime byIt was done by a Jewish western historian named "David Astronach".. Astronaut in the distanceof the year1340 to 1343 in the collectionPasargad palaceHe made some and thatattributed to Achaemenid Cyrus 2,500 years ago rather than to this favorite charactergive the Jews a material and provable historical identity.»
Image above: The area of “Pasargad” and the position of the two palaces S and P in relation to the tomb of Cyrus and the elevated monument “Suleiman prison”
source:
http://www.livius.org/pan-paz/pasargadae/pasargadae.htm
“David Stronach” British archaeologist, in 1340 (1961 AD.) extensive excavations in “Pasargad” started. But before him “Ernst Herzfeld” , the German archaeologist, along with his assistant architect “Friedrich Krafter” In 1307 (1928 AD.) They had started the excavation of Pasargad and with their speculations they had succeeded in determining the floor plan of the two main palaces and the eastern gate.. They also unearthed a number of pillars and bas-reliefs. In 1328 (1949 AD.) “Ali Sami” Under the supervision of the General Directorate of Archeology of Iran, the work continues “Pasargad” took over and He built walls next to the palaces to protect the buildings from the encroachment of farmers and people ...
With these explanations, the title that Mr “unified” by dominating “Stronach” attributes: «Astronach as someone who forged a vile deed and an unforgivable sinHe did Pasargad…»It is a title that he did not actually earn.
Images above: A plan that “Hertsfeld” And “crafter” From the plan site “Pasargad” and the location of the two palaces S and P have provided and in 1941 AD - much earlier than the excavations of “Stronach”- In the book “Iran in the ancient east” It has become a habit.
Source of images: Purada, Adis. Achaemenid art
Mr “unified” Then they blamed the researchers that the role of the building “Gate” The image of Pasargad “blind” have introduced. The author also does not have a song to accompany this group of researchers, he only draws their attention to the fact that although in the current situation, there is no writing representing this role, but according to the evidence of old paintings, including the watercolor painting of “Robert Carporter”British tourist and diplomat, in 1818 AD, one of the many inscriptions in three languages (Ancient Persian, Elamite, and Babylonian) That in the covenant “Dariush” In the buildings of “Pasargad” It was written on top of this role; With this firm word: "I, Cyrus, the king, Achaemenid"
Images above: Designing “Reporter” From the role of the building “Gate” Pasargad, which shows a trilingual inscription with the name “Cyrus” has been above it. This inscription does not exist today and it was removed and taken away!
Image source:
http://www.artarena.force9.co.uk/cyrus1.htm
Image above: On the fold of this role's dress in Koresh's private palace (House P) It is written in Elamite cuneiform on the left and Babylonian on the right: "Koresh, the great king, Achaemenid"
Researchers consider this inscription to be the only one that was engraved in Pasargad by order of Cyrus, and the remaining inscriptions that contain the name “Cyrus” It is by command “Dariush” they know.
Image source:
http://www.livius.org/pan-paz/pasargadae/pasargadae_palace_p.html
Another picture that “Reporter” At the same time from the tomb “blind” in the plain “Pasargad” The presentation shows another building in the background with one raised column and three collapsed columns, which is probably the public hall. (Palace S) is. So Mr “unified” They have said below the description of pictures 14 and 17 of their writing: « This image, the so-called palace S showsIt is known as Baraam Palace. in thisHe also built another palace for Cyrus by pouring a number of pillar cuttingsare." «This is the only remaining column that was mentioned in RasamiOld ones are seen near PersepolisBe and Astronach in the palace S has used." It is wrong.
Image above: Designing “Reporter” From the tomb of Kuresh in the Pasargad plain (1818) which is in the background of the remains of Baraam Palace (Palace S) It is obvious.
Image source:
The British Library / Heritage-Images
Mr “unified” Under the description of pictures 15 and 16 of their writing, they claimed that the columns and materials of a nearby Greek building “Takht-e-Jamshid” By “Stronach” The cost of building palaces “Pasargad” has been Also, under the description of pictures 6 to 11, he expressed his displeasure with the erection of the columns of the private palace of Cyrus. (House P) By “Stronach” Jews have expressed!? In response, the writer informs them that according to the available reports, These stones are under consideration General Department of Archeology of Iran (by the experts of the Italian Institute of the Middle and Far East- Try it ) Around 1971 (1350 solar) On the occasion of the 2,500-year celebrations of the Shahshahi from the same area “Pasargad” (Around the tomb of Cyrus) have been collected and established and “Stronach” It has not played a significant role in this. Report “Ali Sami” In this regard, it is worth reading:
« Around the tomb of Cyrus at irregular intervals (10, 11 and 12 meters) Differently and without observing the directions and points of architecture and engineering in the Islamic eras, they put columns and turned it into a mosque.. This mosque during the reign of Atabak Saad Ibn Zangi (From Atabakan Fars or Selaghians) It was established in the 7th century. The column stones of this mosque were brought from the two palaces of Cyrus, which means that the columns of the east and west porches were replaced with thick columns. “Qasr Bar” (Palace S) The western columns of the north porch with narrow columns “Cyrus' exclusive palace” (House P) have made …» (For more information, see: Pasargad World Heritage Collection information base)
Image above: A plan of Koresh's tomb In 1638 AD. And the columns that were taken from the palaces of Pasargad plain and arranged around it. Effect ” Allbrisht Phone Mandalso”
Image source: Dedicated website of Dr “Kaveh Farrokh”
Image above: A plan of Koresh's tomb From above, which shows the location and distribution of the stone columns arranged around it..
Image source: Hertsfeld – Iran in the ancient east
Really, what would we do if we didn't have you?
Peace be upon you !Cyrus and the great civilization of Iran and its brave and man-oriented kings, and of course, according to the admission of all foreign historians ! Achaemenid Empire is the biggest empire that the world has ever seen !در زمان هخامنشیان نزدیک به پنجاه درصد مردم جهان در فرمان و تحت حمایت و جدو امپراطورى هخامنشیان بودند !این یعنى از هر دونفر جمعیت جهان یک نفر تحت حکومت هخامنشى بودند!! There is no doubt that the above content is a thorn in the eyes of arrogant Goyans and ignorant Arabs! The great and the great-born in the entire history of the blind world, who fear your tomb even after centuries.
Hello Barshma.
Iran's history has had many ups and downs, we are proud that Cyrus and the Achaemenians are among our honors.. Every issue should be analyzed according to the conditions of the time. Of course, Cyrus or our other elders had shortcomings and shortcomings throughout history, but the reason we honor these people is that they ruled differently and better than others in their time.. The enemies of this land and water are aiming to capture our great personalities in the pursuit of identitylessness and domination over Iran and Iranians.
Of course, it might be better to be careful that the Achaemenids ruled half of the world that day. Greek sources knew the extent of the territory of human societies from the east to the easternmost point of Iran, from the south to the vicinity of Arabia and the Red Sea, and from the west to the westernmost parts of Europe, and from the north to Sweden and Flanders, and even less than that. . This means that according to the Greeks, the territory of Iran was about half of the known world of that day. But the truth is that more eastern governments, such as China, are not considered and are unknown to the Greeks.
But in a summary the Achaemenians with more than 8 million square kilometers can be considered the largest empire of the ancient world.
Are you really not ashamed? Ugly brother, no matter how much you burn for the love of the people of Iran and return to yourself, you should not dare to shave your eyebrows, you despicable person.….. Thanks to the Persians of Dej.. Payandeh Iran
Because the homeland is in the hands of foreigners
May the exaggeration of the traitors and traitors be silenced
On the anniversary of the greatness of King Cyrus the Great, they built it in the name of Persepolis of Iran. May the spirit of Cyrus the Great be blessed. May he be victorious and strong.